Due to the success of Singapore’s public housing policy, which begins in the 1960s, 80% of the Singapore’s populace live in HDB flats today.  Private housing are mainly for higher income earners. Those considering buying a residential property in this island nation have to take into account a variety of factors, we will take a closer look at each in turn in this article.

Reason for purchase

First and foremost, buying a property for investment or owner-occupation makes a difference.

Naturally, if it for investment, the chief factor in consideration will be the capital gain.  On the other hand, buying for owner-occupation makes capital gain a secondary concern. In this case, more important factors will be the current or future size of the household. A retiree or single may opt for a smaller flat. While a young, married couple may also choose a small flat if their financial means are limited, or a large flat if they are planning to have children and provided if they are rich enough to afford it.

Type of housing

The next consideration is the housing type. With the many types available, buyers are often spoil for choice. The below two tables compare the private and public housing segments.

Available Housing Types in Singapore

HDB (99-year lease)

Private Housing (60-*, 99-, 999- year lease; freehold)

Build-to-Order (BTO)

  • Studio Apartment (30-year lease)
  • 2-room Flat
  • 3-room Flat
  • 4-room Flat
  • 5-room Flat

Executive Condominium**

Design and Build (DBSS)

Executive Flat (No longer built)

Executive Maisonette (No longer built)

HUDC (No longer built)

 

 

 

Walk-up ApartmentHigh-rise Apartment

Condominium

Shoebox Apartment

Soho

Strata Titled Cluster Housing

  • Inter Terraces
  • Semi Detaches
  • Bungalows

Landed Housing

  • Inter terraces (Type 1 and 2)
  • Corner terraces
  • Semi Detaches
  • Bungalows
  • Good Class Bungalows
  • Sentosa Landed Housing (the only landed properties in Singapore for which foreigners are eligible)

* A land at Jalan Jurong Kechil is the first 60-year lease plot to be sold (on 15 November 2012); thus a 60-year private property will be available in a few years’ time.

** Executive Condominium becomes private after 10 years.

 

Comparison of HDB and Private Housing

HDB Private Housing
Eligibility:Direct Purchase from HDB –

  • Singaporeans
  • Gross Monthly Household Income ≤

$10,000 (For Executive Condominium ≤

$12,000)

Resale –

  • Singaporeans and Permanent Residents

99-year Lease

Most Affordable Type of Housing

For Owner-occupation

Lower Maintenance Cost (Conservancy Charges)

Stringent Restriction for Leasing Out

 

Minimum Occupation Period

Eligibility:Non-landed –

  • Foreigners, Singaporeans and Permanent Residents

Landed –

  • Singaporeans

 

60-*, 99-, 999- year Lease; Freehold

Tend to be More Expensive

For Owner-occupation and Investment

Higher Maintenance Cost (Property Taxes, Monthly Maintenance Charges, etc.)

No Restriction for Leasing Out

 

No Minimum Occupation Period

* A land at Jalan Jurong Kechil is the first 60-year lease plot to be sold (on 15 November 2012); thus a 60-year private property will be available in a few years’ time.

 

To decide which housing type suit the buyer’s budget, a commonly used measure  of housing affordability is the debt-to-service ratio (DSR), defined as

DSR = Monthly Debt Service / Monthly Gross Household Income

The internationally recognised benchmark for housing affordability is a DSR of 30 per cent. For example, based on a household with a monthly income of S$3,000 buying a S$300,000 3-room HDB flat, with no housing grants, the household can take a loan of up 80 per cent of the price (assuming that they have no outstanding mortgage loan), or S$240,000. Given an annual interest rate of 2 per cent, based on a 30-year loan, the monthly installment incurred will be about S$887. This works out to a DSR of roughly 30%, which still falls within the affordable range.

Another widely used affordability measure divides the price of a home by a potential buyer’s annual income.

Nevertheless, these two measures are only short-term measures as buyers’ income may change over time.

To overcome this issue, a long-term measure of housing affordability was developed by Prof Abeysinghe of the National University of Singapore, to find out more about this measure go here.

When deciding between a HDB and private property, besides the affordability, buyers may also want to look at the investment potential of the houses.

HDB flats’ investment potential

From the Government’s standpoint, HDB flats are meant for living purposes and not for speculation. Hence HDB flats are subjected to a Minimum Occupation Period (MOP) of 5 years whether for a resale or direct purchase from HDB. This curbs house flipping of HDB flats.

Nevertheless after MOP, owners of larger HDB flats can make a profit by downgrading to a smaller unit. Those who are tempted to sell for a profit during a booming property market may not be better off as they will have to pay a high price for another flat. Moreover, if their current flat was bought with a housing grant, they will have to incur a resale levy when they buy a second subsidised HDB flat.

However, some Singaporeans are still profiteering from renting out their HDB flats.

Under current regulations, owners of subsidised or non-subsidised HDB flats have to meet the requirement of a 5-year MOP before they are allowed to rent out their flats. Exceptions can be made for owners who live overseas or meet other special conditions.

Furthermore, there are restrictions on the rental periods. For Singaporean owners they could rent out their flats for a period of 3 years after which they could request for extensions with no cap on the number of requests. For PRs, however, it is a different story. They are not allowed to rent out their flats at all. In addition, when buying a HDB flat PRs will have to pay an Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty (ABSD) of 5%.

Private housing’s investment potential

In contrast, the rental rules for private properties are less stringent. Of note is that Singaporeans are not allowed to own HDB flats and private homes concurrently within the MOP.  After the MOP, Singaporeans often make a profit by living in HDB flats while renting out their private properties. Approvals have to be sought from HDB if they wish to living in their private homes and rent out their HDB flats instead.

However, for adventurous homeowners who are looking at flipping private properties to increase their wealth, they are restricted by the string of anti-speculative measures instituted by the Government since 2009.

Properties acquired after 20 February 2010, are subjected to a Sellers’ Stamp Duty of 4% to 16% of the selling price or market value, whichever is higher , if they are disposed of within 1 to 4 years after purchase.

In addition, for property purchases after 12 January 2012, an ABSD of 7%  is imposed on Singaporeans buying their second properties, and 10% on their third and subsequent properties. For PRs, a 5%  ABSD is imposed on their first property, and 7%  on their second and subsequent purchases.


About Property Buyer

http://www.PropertyBuyer.com.sg/mortgage

We are a research-focused Singapore mortgage consultant which helps you compare Singapore home loans either for new home loans or home loan refinancing. We use state- of- the-art home loan reports at http://www.icompareloan.com/ to serve our customers.

SMS :  (65) 9782 8606

Email: loans@PropertyBuyer.com.sg